Almost unrecognizable, right? Let me show you how I completed this transformation!
First, I removed the hardware and patched the holes. Then I added trim around the drawer fronts. I purchased the trim at Home Depot, it is thin enough that it wouldn't stick out too far but added some depth to the piece. I cut the trim to size and then used wood glue to attach it and clamped it overnight to the drawer to dry.
Its already starting to look better! It needed a new top though, as the old top piece seemed nonexistent since it sat flush with the first drawer. I cut new wood to size and then used screws and wood glue to secure. Then let it sit overnight and sanded it all smooth. Here is the piece ready for paint and stain:
I did this to both nightstands. I stained the top a mixture of General Finishes Weathered Gray and Espresso water based stain. I sprayed the drawers and base with General Finishes Lamp Black Milk Paint, then sealed everything with several coats of General Finishes High Performance top coat in Satin. New holes were drilled and the hardware was replaced with new knobs. Here is the final product: